Article 21*
Article 21 – Processor
Commission Proposal
| 1. Member States shall provide that where a processing operation is carried out on behalf of a controller, the controller must choose a processor providing sufficient guarantees to implement appropriate technical and organisational measures and procedures in such a way that the processing will meet the requirements of the provisions adopted pursuant to this Directive and ensure the protection of the rights of the data subject.2. Member States shall provide that the carrying out of processing by a processor must be governed by a legal act binding the processor to the controller and stipulating in particular that the processor shall act only on instructions from the controller, in particular, where the transfer of the personal data used is prohibited.3. If a processor processes personal data other than as instructed by the controller, the processor shall be considered to be a controller in respect of that processing and shall be subject to the rules on joint controllers laid down in Article 20. |
EDRi’s Proposed Amendment
| 1. Member States shall provide that where a processing operation is carried out on behalf of a controller, the controller must choose a processor providing sufficient guarantees to implement appropriate technical and organisational measures and procedures in such a way that the processing will meet the requirements of the provisions adopted pursuant to this Directive and ensure the protection of the rights of the data subject.2. Member States shall provide that the carrying out of processing by a processor must be governed by a legal act binding the processor to the controller. These acts shall in particular stipulate that the processor shall: (a) act only on instructions from the controller, in particular, where the transfer of the personal data used is prohibited; 2a. The controller and the processor shall document in writing the controller’s instructions and the the processor’s obligation referred to in paragraph 2. 3. If a processor processes personal data other than as instructed by the controller, the processor shall be considered to be a controller in respect of that processing and shall be subject to the rules on joint controllers laid down in Article 20. |
Justification
The Commission proposal contains less detailed rules than the equivalent Article 26 of the proposed General Data Protection Regulation. This is unacceptable given that data processed in the scope of this Directive are often of a sensitive nature. The proposed amendment takes language from the proposed General Data Protection Regulation (including EDRi’s proposed amendments to theose provisions) and adapts it to the Directive.

